If you’ve ever sat across the table from a donor, small-talked your way through coffee, and felt your stomach drop the moment it was time to actually name the number, this post is for you.
I recently listened to an episode of The Happiness Lab with Dr. Laurie Santos called “You’re Actually Not Bothering People Enough,” and it landed so squarely on something I see fundraisers wrestle with constantly that I wanted to write it up here. Full credit to Dr. Santos and her guests for the ideas below. I’m just borrowing their research and pointing it at our world. If any of this resonates, go listen to the full 26-minute episode. It’s worth your time.
The fear isn’t unique to you
The episode opens with something almost every fundraiser will recognize instantly: the dread of asking. Not the dread of being told no. The dread of being a burden. Of sitting across from someone, taking up their afternoon, and leaving them feeling cornered or put-upon by the time you get to the ask.
Dr. Santos talks with behavioral scientist Nicholas Epley about why that instinct is so common and so wrong. And she talks with Jia Jiang, who spent 100 days deliberately asking strangers for outlandish favors just to get comfortable with rejection, about what he learned in the process. Between the two of them, a pretty clear picture emerges: we are consistently, measurably bad at predicting how our requests land on other people.
The research: we underestimate how good it feels to help
The core finding Epley discusses comes from a study he ran with researcher Xuan Zhao, published in Psychological Science in 2022 and titled “Surprisingly Happy to Have Helped.” Across more than 2,000 participants, the pattern held up again and again: people who needed help consistently underestimated how willing others would be to give it, underestimated how good it would make the helper feel, and overestimated how inconvenienced the helper would be.
In other words, when you ask someone for something, you’re running a mental simulation of their reaction and that simulation is skewed. You imagine irritation. They mostly feel useful.
There’s a reason for the skew, too. The researchers found we tend to think about “being asked” through the lens of compliance as if the other person is being cornered into saying yes. But the people doing the helping don’t experience it that way at all. They experience it as an opportunity to act on values they already hold. Being asked doesn’t make someone feel obligated. It makes someone feel needed.
This is, essentially, the entire argument for philanthropy in one sentence: giving isn’t something people do reluctantly when cornered; it’s something people want to do, and an ask is often the permission they were waiting for.
Jia Jiang and the “beautiful mess”
The other half of the episode comes from Jia Jiang’s story. After a business rejection left him rattled, he set out on “100 Days of Rejection Therapy” deliberately asking for absurd things (a burger refill at a fast-food counter, to plant a flower in a stranger’s yard, to fly a plane) specifically to desensitize himself to “no.” What he found wasn’t rejection. It was that people were far more open, and far kinder, than he expected. And the moments where he was most honest and most vulnerable about what he wanted were the moments people responded to best.
That tracks with a concept the episode also cites: the “beautiful mess effect,” research showing that we judge our own vulnerability far more harshly than others do. When we show a little bit of need, or admit that something matters a lot to us, we assume it looks weak. Other people, watching from the outside, don’t see weakness. They see honesty and honesty is what builds trust.
What this means for your next ask
None of this is a stretch to translate into fundraising. It is fundraising, minus the framing that’s been drilled into us. So here’s the reframe:
You are not interrupting your donor’s day by sitting down with them. You’re offering them a chance to feel useful. The instinct to soften a face-to-face ask by circling the number for ten extra minutes of small talk, hedging it with qualifiers, apologizing before the words are even out, comes from the same miscalibration Epley’s research documents. You’re picturing your donor’s irritation as you drive to the meeting. Statistically, that’s not what’s waiting on the other side of the table.
Specificity is a gift, not an imposition. A vague ask (“any support helps!”) avoids the discomfort of naming a real number in the room, but it also strips the donor of the thing that actually makes giving feel good: knowing exactly what their gift does. Jia Jiang’s most successful asks, made face to face with total strangers, were his clearest ones. Look your donor in the eye and tell them what the $250 does. Let them picture it, right there in the conversation.
Your sincerity is doing more work than your polish. If the “beautiful mess effect” holds, the moment in the meeting that feels most exposed, the plain, unrehearsed sentence about why this program matters, the honest admission that you’re nervous to ask, is landing better with your donor than you think it is. Reaching for a smoother, safer script in that moment may be costing you connection, not gaining you credibility.
Reframe “bothering” as “including.” This is maybe the most useful mental shift for a solicitation meeting specifically. The person sitting across from you chose, at some point, to care about your mission. Asking them, in person, isn’t you extracting something from them. It’s you handing them another opportunity to act on a value they already hold, face to face, in real time. That’s not an imposition. That’s stewardship.
The takeaway
Fundraisers spend a lot of energy managing the discomfort of asking. Energy that, per the research, is largely spent guarding against a reaction that isn’t actually happening on the other end. Your donors are not counting the ways you’ve bothered them. Most of them are glad you thought of them.
If you want the fuller version of this argument, including Jia Jiang’s actual stories from his 100 days, which are worth hearing in his own words, go listen to the episode: “You’re Actually Not Bothering People Enough,” from The Happiness Lab with Dr. Laurie Santos.
And then book that meeting you’ve been putting off. Sit down, say the number plainly and specifically, and stop apologizing for it.